Difference between DOI and Handle system
Hi Community, DOI and Handle are two widely used persistent URI methods. I am wondering if there are any difference between those two and which system we shall select. I have come across a few preprint records where the record is a copy of record hosted in an original preprint server and the DOI in the copied server is referencing to the original server's URL. Should digital libraries need to refer to only original URI? Thank you for your inputs. Best regards, Atanu Atanu Garai SocialWell m: +91 97761.83915 a: Flat T-11/805, Tata Ariana, Mahalaxmi Vihar, Bhubaneswar, Odisha 751029 IN w: www.socialwell.nethttp://www.socialwell.net/ e: atanu@socialwell.netmailto:atanu@socialwell.net -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.
Hello
This may be a matter related to copyright, someone might have fetched the
record from the original so for the full-text document, they are referring
to the original. A similar practice is used by our National Digital
Library. Sorry if I don't understand your question.
With Regards,
Vinod Kumar Mishra,
Assistant Librarian,
Biju Patnaik Central Library (BPCL),
NIT Rourkela,
Sundergadh-769008,
Odisha,
India.
Mob:91+9439420860
URL: http://vinod.itshelp.co.in/
ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4666-7874
Scopus ID: 57223138343
*"Spiritual relationship is far more precious than physical. Physical
relationship divorced from spiritual is body without soul" -- Mahatma
Gandhi*
On Tue, Sep 20, 2022 at 5:50 PM Atanu Garai
Hi Community, DOI and Handle are two widely used persistent URI methods. I am wondering if there are any difference between those two and which system we shall select.
I have come across a few preprint records where the record is a copy of record hosted in an original preprint server and the DOI in the copied server is referencing to the original server's URL. Should digital libraries need to refer to only original URI?
Thank you for your inputs.
Best regards, Atanu
Atanu Garai
SocialWell m: +91 97761.83915 a: Flat T-11/805, Tata Ariana, Mahalaxmi Vihar, Bhubaneswar, Odisha 751029 IN w: www.socialwell.nethttp://www.socialwell.net/ e: atanu@socialwell.net mailto:atanu@socialwell.net
-- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.
From what I understand, the DOI service is based on the CNRI Handle system
itself. The DOI service is geared more towards the commercial publishers.
Users of DOI need to pay for each DOI generated, besides annual fees
starting at USD 275 per year (https://www.crossref.org/fees/).
The Handle system is available on a fixed fee of USD 50 per year
irrespective of the number of documents. Software like DSpace and EPrints
can use both DOI or Handles. For non-commercial digital libraries, like
academic institutions, the Handle system is preferred. Both systems use the
same underlying technology platform.
You can read more about it here:
https://www.doi.org/factsheets/DOIHandle.html
Best regards,
Saiful Amin
Semantic Consulting Services Pvt. Ltd.
Bangalore
On Tue, Sep 20, 2022 at 5:50 PM Atanu Garai
Hi Community, DOI and Handle are two widely used persistent URI methods. I am wondering if there are any difference between those two and which system we shall select.
I have come across a few preprint records where the record is a copy of record hosted in an original preprint server and the DOI in the copied server is referencing to the original server's URL. Should digital libraries need to refer to only original URI?
Thank you for your inputs.
Best regards, Atanu
Atanu Garai
SocialWell m: +91 97761.83915 a: Flat T-11/805, Tata Ariana, Mahalaxmi Vihar, Bhubaneswar, Odisha 751029 IN w: www.socialwell.nethttp://www.socialwell.net/ e: atanu@socialwell.net mailto:atanu@socialwell.net
Hi Community,
Thank you for providing your inputs on this question, as summarized below:
1. Q1: Selection between DOI vs. Handle system
a) Both the systems use the underlying Handle infrastructure provided by CNRI. However, there is significant cost implications for using DOI and it enabled the commercial publishers to adopt DOI, while the academic institutions have been using Handle system.
b) DOI webpage provides various points on the comparisons between both the systems here: https://www.doi.org/factsheets/DOIHandle.html
2. Q2: Need for using a single DOI/ Handle identifier for the same resource
a) A single resource can be hosted by multiple repositories. However, they may use a single resource identifier (DOI or Handle), to enable to point to the original source copy, to improve attribution as may be required from licensing/ copyright point of view.
Thank you, Dr. Saiful Amin and Dr. Vinod Mishra, for your inputs.
SocialWell is building a modern digital library framework that can deliver most of the resource types. We would be interested to listen to specific requirements that you feel are not available in existing frameworks.
Best regards,
Atanu
Atanu Garai
SocialWell
m: +91 97761.83915
a: Flat T-11/805, Tata Ariana, Mahalaxmi Vihar, Bhubaneswar, Odisha 751029 IN
w: www.socialwell.net e: atanu@socialwell.net
-----Original Message-----
From: Dr. Saiful Amin
Hi Community, DOI and Handle are two widely used persistent URI methods. I am wondering if there are any difference between those two and which system we shall select.
I have come across a few preprint records where the record is a copy of record hosted in an original preprint server and the DOI in the copied server is referencing to the original server's URL. Should digital libraries need to refer to only original URI?
Thank you for your inputs.
Best regards, Atanu
Atanu Garai
SocialWell m: +91 97761.83915 a: Flat T-11/805, Tata Ariana, Mahalaxmi Vihar, Bhubaneswar, Odisha 751029 IN w: www.socialwell.nethttp://www.socialwell.net/ e: atanu@socialwell.net mailto:atanu@socialwell.net
-------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://ncsi.iisc.ernet.in/pipermail/lis-forum/attachments/20220920/15ef3c5f/... _______________________________________________ LIS-Forum mailing list LIS-Forum@ncsi.iisc.ernet.in http://ncsi.iisc.ernet.in/mailman/listinfo/lis-forum
participants (3)
-
Atanu Garai -
Dr. Saiful Amin -
vinod mishra