Date: Mon, 5 Jun 2006 From: Usha Mujoo-Munshi Reference : Please review our article titled "Open Access and institutional repositories - a developing country perspective: a case study of India" (Puna Das) At the ouset i must compliment the author/s for a commendable work. A good review on OA IRs. While going through the contents, some discripencies regarding INSA data was observed. 1. INSA OA repositories using Dspace are not only metadata, communities like seminar reports, presentations, photo-gallery are complete communities. However many items under articles are though metadata level. 2. INSA journals are online from inception while dates(year) mentioned are not correct. Kindly update.