Barbara Kirsop on Open access and developing countries

From Peter Suber's blog:
Background on the Bangalore model national OA policy
Barbara Kirsop, Creating a National Open Access Policy
for Developing Countries, Open and Shut, November 29,
2006. Excerpt:
Meeting in the idyllic surroundings of the Indian
Institute of Science campus, in Bangalore, the 44
participants of the [Workshop on electronic publishing
and open access, November 2-3, 2006] included
scientists and OA experts from India, China, Brazil
and South Africa, along with colleagues and OA
advocates from a number of other countries....
[W]hy was it felt necessary to hold a workshop on
OA so soon after the Salvador Declaration on Open
Access for Developing Countries, held in September
2005? The Bangalore workshop was not intended to be a
venue simply for confirming acceptance of the
principles of OA, but was convened to bring some of
the most scientifically advanced developing countries
together to report on progress, and consider a model
National Open Access Policy that could be offered to
governments, and their funding organisations, as a
practical tool for driving OA forward.
The aim, therefore, was to take the next step
towards ensuring the implementation of earlier OA
declarations, not just to talk about OA....
[S]ince the cost of academic journals is
prohibitive for many developing countries, scholarly
communication is for them severely restricted. This
is a huge problem: A survey conducted by the WHO in
2003, for instance, found that in 75 of the poorest
countries, 56% of the medical institutions had been
unable to access any journals over the previous five
years....
Furthermore, the cost of printing and distributing
local journals means that much developing world
research is 'invisible' to the rest of the world....As
a consequence, the incorporation of regional knowledge
into international programmes remains minimal. Yet
with the growth of global problems think only of
HIV/AIDS, avian 'flu, environmental disasters, climate
change or crop failure it is essential that the
countries in which these problems are most commonly
experienced have access to research findings, and can
contribute their crucial experience to finding global
solutions.
Without both improved access and regional
visibility, the science base of poorer countries will
not be strengthened, and it is well documented that
without a strong science base economies remain weak
and dependent on others....
It is clear...that wherever researchers have
embraced OA, the visibility, quality and the impact of
local research has flourished, and subscriptions to OA
journals have even increased a clear indication that
researchers were previously information-starved....
One Indian institute...is 'gently persuading' its
scholars to deposit their articles by refusing travel
support to those that do not archive their
publications!...
It was agreed...that progress could be
significantly speeded up if a model National OA Policy
could be drawn up, and developing countries encouraged
to adopt it. It was also felt that this would be
particularly effective if it was formally accepted by
a group of local experts of which there was no
shortage at the workshop who know and understand the
problems faced by developing countries on the ground.
While there was vigorous debate on how to encourage
adoption of such a policy, there was no dissent over
the need for it, or of its basic form.
Specifically, the draft Policy document urges
governments to require all publicly funded research
published in peer-reviewed journals to be deposited in
an institutional repository as soon as publication is
accepted. This should be a condition for research
funding for any papers partly or fully funded by the
government....
All presentations, lists of participants and the
draft model National OA Policy document are available
on the workshop web site.
participants (1)
-
Subbiah Arunachalam